Questions & discussions

von Playaveli · 21.08.2019 13:55 · 20 Antworten · 23 Aufrufe
21.08.2019 13:55 #1
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
Anything not clear? Ask here... 8)
21.08.2019 16:17 #2
G
Gorzo
199 Beiträge
When will be a table price?! 😛
21.08.2019 16:37 #3
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
Use price table in skill generator 9.99!
Only thing to be corrected: Top GK price = 4.5M (so every goallkeeper which has 60M or more on transfermarkt.com = 4.5M!)

Careful: There are DIFFERENT price tables for every different role (GK, D, RB LB, M, LW RW, A)
23.08.2019 09:13 #4
K
Kanchelskis
130 Beiträge
Just a suggestion: don t use transfermarkt parameters to generate skills, player skills are random and based on his market values. A youngster is already a superstar compared to a strong 30yrs old player while he has maybe everything to demonstrate. Also players playing in England, Spain, Germany and Italy are way stronger than someone on the same level playing in Scotland. Generally talking teams are overrated and gamplay become easier.
A better way is to have FIFA or PES or FM skills value and convert it into actual SWOS value (i.e. if a player is rated 80 in FIFA, in SWOS is 2mln).

Another thing I found broken is that 4-2-4 module is used for quite every team that field a 4-2-3-1 module. Totally wrong, the first one is a very attacking old module you can use when you are losing, while the second one is a very equilibrated and defensive module, more similar to a 4-5-1.
Both the main modules widely used today are a 4-5-1: modern 4-3-3 is actually more a 4-5-1 where the side forwards are not attackers but wings often involved in defense; 4-2-3-1 even worse.
When you have in SWOS two teams using a 4-2-4 is so easy to pass through midfield and score bunches of goals, most of all if you are Barça and playing against a weak team with that module.

Just my two cents.
23.08.2019 10:29 #5
S
sensibleswos
229 Beiträge
I know that you have to have different ways of updating in order to keep the game updated with today standards. Sadly I won t be helping on the updates as I find the new ways confusing. I still use 0-7 7-15 skills like original data. I hope to see new swos with updated league structures and new national leagues. From what I ve seen so far you have all done an amazing job, I understand the time and effort you have given it. Will you be adding a new swos editor? from what I ve read and seen on the things you ve added or like to add it s going to need one. Looking forward to swos 2020.
23.08.2019 12:06 #6
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
Updates will never be perfect!
With the new rules we will surely do a better job as on 16/17 which was a great effort I think, with many people contributing.

Especially this will make sure to balance it to a 96/97 feeling:
Skill range: 0-7

- Maximum skill points possible: 555 (Italy 96/97)
- Maximum total speed points per team: 82 (Italy Barca of 96/97)
- Maximum of 7 players with 4.5 stars or more (Italy 96/97)
- Maximum players with Speed 7 = 8 players per team (Barcelona 96/97)
- Maximum goalkeeper prize = 4.5 M


Armando s skill gen 9.99 does a great job in taking different positions into regard when it comes to price/skill calculation, also age factor!

@ Kanchelskis: FIFA or PES? WTF no.... 😛 😁
23.08.2019 14:39 #7
P
petarku
57 Beiträge
playaveli what is the formula he is using for age ? we should know it if we are not using armando s excel or it is mandatory ?
while i can understand why we have different formula for different positions for expensive players , I dont understand why the formula is different for the cheaper players.. (RB in LB under 1m) ? what is logic behind that ?
23.08.2019 16:10 #8
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
Hi

age in excel work:

31 = value x 1.25
32- 34 = value x 1.5
35-37 = value x 2
38-39 = value x 2.5
40-50 = value x 3

you can use manually with a calculator
23.08.2019 16:19 #9
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
if we want teams with the limit of 96-97, we need diferents tables, in swos 96-97 players rb,lb and lw, rw not have hight values like A , lw and rw some cracks players

check real madrid
http://swos.gazchap.com/index.php?teamid=1040
barcelona
http://swos.gazchap.com/index.php?teamid=124

this is real madrid with the excel
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/239363794617237505/614450332386328761/unknown.png
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/239363794617237505/614450397058170900/unknown.png


this automatic, only change hazard per A and modric add , because price is low and 33 years, benzema per jovic 1-11
and down speed too, no all automatic per 80% yes

the tables per role can be changed, you can test this for find the best values from transfermark to swos
maybe D , VARANE 70M must be 6 M not 8M, but all is test


https://www.dropbox.com/s/jt0ibfz2rqwrrt7/Simple%20Skill%20Generador.xlsm?dl=0
27.08.2019 10:59 #10
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
PM sent to all editors to a private Discord server!
Contains info on where to upload team files.
29.08.2019 15:32 #11
K
Kanchelskis
130 Beiträge
Playaveli · 23.08.2019 12:06:
@ Kanchelskis: FIFA or PES? WTF no.... 😛 😁



Synchronated used FIFA and FM parameters for his updates
29.08.2019 16:00 #12
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
Kanchelskis · 29.08.2019 15:32:
Playaveli · 23.08.2019 12:06:
@ Kanchelskis: FIFA or PES? WTF no.... 😛 😁



Synchronated used FIFA and FM parameters for his updates


I know he did. That s fine. I was more like saying it out of old rivarly to this modern shit 😉 !
In the end, it doesn t matter what you use, as long as it works and is well balanced in 96/97 tradition.
But when you do an update, you have to decide for one route... otherwise it gets messed up.
31.08.2019 12:44 #13
R
Rock and Roll
2491 Beiträge
In the Price Table the RB,LB values have a mistake.
65k SWOS goes from 55k to 80k
75k SWOS goes from 161k to 185k
What are the correct boundaries?

Thanks!
31.08.2019 19:48 #14
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
yes

Price Table the RB,LB
65k SWOS goes from 55k to 80k
75k SWOS goes from 81k to 185k
01.09.2019 12:07 #15
R
Rock and Roll
2491 Beiträge
Thanks, but I don t agree with this step.
The 75k boundaries are 105k apart.
Before that 25k, above that 40k.
I think it is better to take the 75k boundaries as 81-125k then convert the categories above accordingly.

I also have a problem with the 75k boundaries for all other positions.
Between brackets the approximate class width (not going into Maths discussions here 🙂 ).
65k: 55-80 (25)
75k: 81-140 (60)
85k: 141-160 (20)
100k: 161-185 (25)
110k: 186-225 (40)
130k: 226-275 (50)

Here the 75k boundaries don t feel right. I think we should adjust them here too.

This has all to do with the teams in lesser leagues. Shortening the 75k boundaries will give a few
more differences so should increase the fun.

One thing I have noticed while doing the Faroe Islands this time, is the massive increase in players
with a Transfermarket value. Three years ago, there were very few players with a value (e.g. the
2015 winners B36 Torshavn only had 4 players with a value). This time, 15 players in B36 have a
value. I still guess El Salvador will be a lot of no value players though 😀 .


Greetz,

Rock
01.09.2019 12:24 #16
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
this is the table rb ,lb

100K 0,275 0,226
85K 0,225 0,186
75K 0,185 0,081
65K 0,08 0,055
50K 0,054 0,041
40K 0,04 0,029
30K 0,028 0,021
25K 0,02 0,001

which changes do you recommend?
and other roles tables. i didnt have time for thoroughly review the tables, if you could help o recommend changes 🙂
01.09.2019 13:31 #17
R
Rock and Roll
2491 Beiträge
Idea for all tables from 65-160k
All boundaries *1000 (k).

RB/LB
65k: 55-80
75k: 81-120
85k: 121-170
100k: 171-230
110k: 231-290
130k: 291-360
150k: 361-450
160k: 451-550

All other roles have the same table for these values.
So:

65k: 55-80
75k: 81-110
85k: 111-140
100k: 141-180
110k: 181-220
130k: 221-270
150k: 271-330
160k: 331-400
180k: 401-480
200k: 481-560
250k: 561-699

Discuss 🙂
01.09.2019 14:09 #18
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
Very good , i think your update is better 😉

thanks , i am going to update the tables
01.09.2019 14:12 #19
R
Rock and Roll
2491 Beiträge
Thanks mate!
01.09.2019 14:26 #20
A
armandojimenez
123 Beiträge
Simple Skill Generador and Skill Generator (transfermarkt) v9.991 updated with better values
01.09.2019 15:36 #21
P
Playaveli Themenstarter
9694 Beiträge
Good work, guys! Updated downloads in Discord.